Getting Involved with the Editorial Process Q&A
The academic community is about more than just publishing research. In short, you can get involved at any stage of the editorial process, including acting as a reviewer, Guest Editor, or Editor-in-Chief.
Because this side of participation is not the central aspect of our operations, there are usually loads of questions about it.
So, we’ve compiled this short list of questions and answers with the hope of guiding those interested in collaborating with us.
If your question isn’t answered here, leave us a comment below!
How do I volunteer to review for an MDPI journal?
We welcome new reviewers!
To apply to become a reviewer, log into the SuSy portal, and then fill out the volunteer reviewer form.
Then, you’ll typically be contacted within three working days by the journal’s Managing Editor with further details.
Meanwhile, you can find guidelines for MDPI reviewers on our website.
How can I become a Guest Editor/Editor-in-Chief/Editorial Board Member?
- Guest Editor
You can nominate yourself to be a Guest Editor. Firstly, you’ll need to either propose a topic or propose a Special Issue.
- Editor-in-Chief or Editorial Board Member
These positions are offered to academics in specific fields who meet the requirements of the journal. To accept an invitation, simply reply to the email expressing your interest.
Is there any guidance for Guest Editors/Editors-in-Chief/Editorial Board Members?
You can find this on our information for editors page.
Then, you can reach out to the journal’s Editorial Office for further details.
Is the institutional membership program free?
The Institutional Open Access Program (IOAP) is free for institutions to join for the first year. After the first year, institutions can pay a fee and receive even larger discounts for their authors. Membership is flexible and you can cancel at any time.
If you’re an interested academic, you can recommend the IOAP membership scheme to your librarian.
For further details, please see the IOAP memberships page.
Where can I submit a proposal for a new journal?
You can send it in via email to the journal’s Editorial Office.
Above all, make sure that you include:
- an outline of the proposed scope;
- a list of potential Editorial Board Members;
- a few lines about how the journal will contribute to the field.
Does MDPI support conferences?
Yes, MDPI financially supports some conferences.
In addition, you can use conference organisation tool Sciforum to plan your conference.
For instance, Sciforum can help you:
- Set up a website for your conference
- Receive abstracts
- Register attendees
- Send out mass emails
- Register doi numbers
- Export attendee data
Moreover, Sciforum has a free version ready to use.
If you can’t find a specific answer to a question, let us know in the comment section below.
Article originally published by Martyn Rittman in November 2015.
Hi,
I have a question about my application to volunteer as a reviewer. It has been shown as ‘Your application is pending decision’ for around two weeks. Is there any way to speed up this process? Thanks.
Hello,
Due to various reasons, like national holidays or annual leave, there can be certain delays in responses and backlogs. Please try to get in contact directly with the journal’s editorial office; you can find their email on the journal homepage. I hope this helps to answer your question.
Dear Katherine,
I am trying to get involved into the volunteer review for those three journals, Current Oncology, Medical Science and Pathophysiology. Because the scope of these journal matches my specialty and interest the most. But there are two months passing away, I haven’t received any update in the status, and it still shows as “Your application is pending decision”. I don’t know how long it actually takes for the journal’s Managing Editor to make the decision, but I was told usually the response will be made within three days. Could you please tell me what I should do to fasten the process or gain more chance? Thanks
Hello,
I have applied via the Susy form for volunteering as a reviewer, including all information. But for ten days, there has been written “pending decision”. Can you please help me how long this status will remain?
Hello Marco,
Unfortunately we are unable to provide you with specific details as we do not have access to the journal’s information. We encourage you to reach out to the journal for more details. We hope this helps.
Hello Dear Katherine Bosworth, I submitted my research paper in the Axioms Journal with manuscript ID: axioms-2242258 on 09-02-2023 and revised version on 29-03-2023. Since 10-04-2023 the status of our research paper is “Pending Editor Decision”. Could you please tell me still how much will it take in final decision?
Thanks
Hi Dr. Ali, thank you for the comment.
I understand that this situation is very frustrating. I recommend reaching out to the Axioms Editorial Office directly. They’ll be able to provide you with an update on your manuscript.
Dear Katherine,
I want to become a Guest Editor in MDPI Journal of my research domain.What are the process?Let me know.
Kind regards,
Md Osim Aquatar,PhD (AcSIR,India & CSIR-NEERI)
Email -mdaquatar.88@gmail.com)
Hi Md Osim, thanks for the comment.
Take a look at the information under ‘How can I become a Guest Editor/Editor-in-Chief/Editorial Board Member?’ in this article. You’ll need to either propose a topic or propose a Special Issue.
Hello
I have a question.
After editor pending decision, i do not know why the status changed to :revised version review”, it is quite unusual and i do not know why the status comes again, please is there any issues on my paper? thanks for your attention.
Hi Paul, thanks for the comment.
This status means that your paper is going through the second round of reviews. You can find out more information about what your manuscript status means in our blog article on this topic.
Dear Katherine Bosworth,
We have submitted our revised manuscript on February 20, 2023 to Processes (Manuscript ID
processes-2210544) and it is quite unusual that the status is still revised version review. Although, It as been almost 17 days since the submission of revised manuscript. Kindly do the needful.
Hello Dr. Ud Din Wani, thank you for getting in touch.
The review stage usually takes around 1-2 weeks. This includes revised version reviews. I recommend getting in touch with the Processes Editorial Office.